Skip to main content

US Treasury’s Proposed Crypto Wallet Rule Is Unconstitutional, Warns Civil Rights Group

US Treasury’s Proposed Crypto Wallet Rule Is Unconstitutional, Warns Civil Rights Group

The New Civil Liberties Alliance has objected to FinCEN’s proposed crypto wallet rule, calling it “unlawful.” In addition, the group says that the U.S. Treasury’s “planned ‘crackdown’ on cryptocurrency holders’ private wallets is an unconstitutional power grab.”

FinCEN’s Proposed Crypto Wallet Rule Is Unlawful, Says NCLA

The New Civil Liberties Alliance (NCLA), a nonpartisan, nonprofit civil rights group, filed its comments on Monday objecting to FinCEN’s proposed rule, entitled “Requirements for Certain Transactions Involving Convertible Virtual Currency or Digital Assets.” The Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) is a bureau of the U.S. Treasury Department.

The NCLA warned:

The U.S. Treasury Department’s planned ‘crackdown’ on cryptocurrency holders’ private wallets is an unconstitutional power grab … The proposed rule represents a radical — and unlawful — extension of FinCEN’s financial surveillance.

The group calls FinCEN’s proposal a “large-scale state intrusion into private digital transactions,” asserting that its “unlawful requirements … would lead to a massive collection of people’s personal information” and would “likely force privacy-sensitive digital assets out of the U.S. banking system.”

Under the proposal, “digital assets would fall into the ‘monetary instruments’ category of regulated currencies,” the NCLA explained. This means private data of bitcoin and other crypto users would be collected as mandated by the Bank Secrecy Act’s (BSA) record-keeping and currency transaction reporting requirements.

Furthermore, FinCEN’s proposed rule “sets in motion a chain reaction of personal information mandatory disclosure,” the NCLA described. For example, whenever a financial institution makes a transaction involving cryptocurrencies worth more than $3,000 with a person, even if the individual is using an unhosted wallet, it must keep detailed records concerning both the customer and the counterparty. The NCLA pointed out that “Even existing BSA requirements for traditional banks do not require this level of disclosure about counterparties.” The alliance argues:

The proposed rule exceeds appropriate constitutional limits by empowering FinCEN to exercise Congress’ exclusive legislative power.

The group further explained that “the proposed rule violates the Fourth Amendment by extending the BSA’s reach to require production of sensitive financial information from those who have never voluntarily disclosed it to a financial institution, and who, like cryptocurrency owners, have been excluded from the BSA’s reach.” The NCLA emphasized that “It would unconstitutionally require disclosure of private information to law enforcement without any suspicion of wrongdoing,” subsequently urging FinCEN to “recognize constitutional limits on its authority and to halt its unlawful rulemaking.”

Caleb Kruckenberg, NCLA’s litigation counsel, commented:

FinCEN’s proposed rule unlawfully attempts to transform the agency’s limited authority to regulate banks into permission to engage in the mass financial surveillance of innocent individuals who merely use digital assets. FinCEN ought to recognize that its proposal would be grossly unconstitutional and promptly scrap this rule.

Do you agree with the NCLA on FinCEN’s crypto rule? Let us know in the comments section below.



from Bitcoin News https://ift.tt/2QLNYhI

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Deep Web Roundup: Dream Adds Monero and Bitcoin Tumbler “Chip Mixer” Launches

The darknet has been quiet of late, which is the way it’s meant to be. No news means no mega busts, honeypots, or mass market shutdowns. Even when it’s out of the spotlight though, the deep web is quietly making news, whether trialling the latest privacy coins or the newest coin mixers that promise to restore a little of the privacy that’s being stripped away from bitcoin users on a daily basis. Also read: U.S. Agency ICE Conducts Investigations That Exploit Blockchain Activity The Battle for Privacy Heats Up Privacy is all relative, but of late there’s been relatively little privacy to be enjoyed by bitcoin users. Blockchain monitoring software is becoming more sophisticated and more common, with U.S. law enforcement agencies using it to profile and hunt down deep web users. Chip Mixer is a relatively new bitcoin tumbler that’s designed to restore some of that privacy. Available on both the clearnet and darknet, the service uses a variety of techniques to obfuscate blockchain m

International Crypto Exchange Luno Adds Bitcoin Cash Trading

Luno exchange has added bitcoin cash trading to the platform following feedback from its client base. BCH is now only the third cryptocurrency available for trading on the exchange, in addition to BTC and ETH , but more options could be on the way once Luno determines that they are credible enough. Also Read: Bitflyer Adds Bitcoin Cash Trading Across Europe and the US Luno Adds Bitcoin Cash Trading Luno, the London-headquartered company formerly known as Bitx, recently announced that bitcoin cash was made available on its cryptocurrency exchange. Starting from Monday, September 23, customers at Luno are now able to store, buy and sell BCH on the platform. The reason given for adding BCH to the exchange is feedback from users in developing markets that convinced Luno to expand their offering from previously just BTC and ETH . Marcus Swanepoel, CEO of Luno, said , “We are in a new and exciting financial era. Developing economies are leading the large-scale adoption and appli

Ombudsman Receives Complaints About Crypto Investments in Spain

The Spanish ombudsman has been receiving complaints about cryptocurrency and how some Spanish citizens investing in these vehicles have lost everything. In his annual report, Angel Gabilondo recognized the rise of cryptocurrencies as a new problem due to the little or no regulation crypto sees in the country. In the same way, the EU has also warned about these assets recently. Spanish Ombudsman Gives His Take on Crypto Angel Gabilondo, the Spanish ombudsman, has given his take regarding cryptocurrencies and the effects they have on citizens investing in some of these projects. Gabilondo said in his yearly report that cryptocurrencies have become “a new problem” during the year examined, with many people having lost all of their funds invested. The report states : Cryptocurrency exchange companies or platforms are not regulated in the legal system, are not subject to any public supervision system, nor do they benefit from deposit guarantee systems. The affected users that sought